Brown Sugar vs White Sugar: Which one is Better?

Explore the key differences between brown sugar vs white sugar in baking and their calories. Learn which sugar is better for diabetics and for health benefits.

10/9/20244 min read

White Sugar vs Brown Sugar
White Sugar vs Brown Sugar

Brown Sugar vs White Sugar

There are so many types of sugar out there, brown sugar and white sugar are the most common ones. These two sugars are the standard in a lot of baking and coffee sweetening recipes. So, what's the real difference between them? Brown sugar is essentially white sugar mixed with molasses, which gives it a darker color and a slightly different flavor. But there’s more to it – they vary in taste, how they're used in baking, how they're produced, and even in their nutrient content, although just a little. We'll explain the key differences between brown and white sugar in this article so you can choose the one that's best for you.

What Is White Granulated Sugar?

Sugarcane or sugar beet plants are the source of white sugar, commonly known as granulated sugar. These plants store sugar as juice through photosynthesis, from which it is subsequently harvested and refined. To manufacture white sugar, which is what most people use for baking and cooking on a daily basis, the juice is filtered and crystallized. There are several types of sugar depending on how it is refined, but granulated sugar is the most common and is mostly used to bake cakes and biscuits or stirred into tea or coffee.

What Is Brown Sugar?

Brown sugar is basically white sugar with molasses added back in to give it additional moisture, a softer texture, and a richer flavor closer to caramel. The most common type of brown sugar is light brown sugar, however dark brown sugar has nearly twice as much molasses as light brown sugar. Remember that dark brown sugar has a stronger flavor when using it in recipes.

The disadvantage of brown sugar is that it can sometimes turn hard if not stored properly. Ever open a brown sugar bag and discover it's as solid as a rock? That's as a result of the wetness drying up. To avoid this, keep your brown sugar soft and useful by storing it in an airtight container.

White Sugar and Brown Sugar
White Sugar and Brown Sugar

Difference Between Brown Sugar vs White Sugar

While both can be substituted in some recipes, brown and white sugars have different uses. For example, dark brown sugar is a great addition to recipes calling for a deeper flavor such as spice cakes, gingerbreads, and even barbecue sauces. On the other hand, light brown sugar works well in marinades and sweet sauces. It's usually safe to use light brown sugar in recipes that don't specify which kind to use.

There are also other types of brown sugar, each with its own uses:

Turbinado: This raw sugar is processed using steam and has a little molasses flavor. Its golden crystals are perfect for bringing in a touch of gentle sweetness.

Demerara: This sugar has a rough texture and is frequently added to cocktails to give them a little crunch.

Muscovado: This less refined sugar is excellent in anything from oatmeal to barbecue sauces because it holds more molasses.

White sugar also comes in a few varieties, based on crystal size:

Granulated Sugar: The most popular kind, perfect for regular sweetening and baking.

Sanding Sugar: This sparkling sugar is mostly used to decorate baked items.

Superfine Sugar: It dissolves fast, making it an excellent choice for desserts like mousses or puddings. It is also known as caster sugar.

Powdered Sugar: This powdered sugar is made from granulated sugar and is frequently used for whipped cream or icing.

Powder and cubes of white and brown sugar
Powder and cubes of white and brown sugar

Brown Sugar vs White Sugar: Which is Better?

The decision between brown and white sugar comes down to personal preferences for both flavor and look. Because of the molasses, brown sugar contains just a little more minerals, but not enough to significantly affect your health. The real issue with both types of sugar is overconsumption. Eating too much sugar may lead to heart disease, type 2 diabetes, and obesity. Although 5–10% of your daily calories should come from added sugar, you should aim for even less for best health.

Brown Sugar vs White Sugar Benefits

Contrary to what some might think, brown and white sugar are very similar in nutrition. Because of the molasses, brown sugar has a tiny bit more calcium, iron, and potassium, but not enough to make a noticeable difference in health. Any sort of sugar should be consumed in limit.

Brown Sugar vs White Sugar Calories

Both sugars have almost the same number of calories per teaspoon about 15 calories for brown sugar and 16.3 calories for white sugar because they come from the same plant, sugarcane or sugar beets. The main difference is the molasses, which changes the taste and color but not the calorie count significantly.

Brown Sugar vs White Sugar in Baking

The kind of sugar you use can have a huge impact on baking results. The moisture content of brown sugar, generated from molasses, helps to the thicker, chewier texture of baked goods such as chocolate chip cookies or brownies. White sugar, on the other hand, works well for cookies that are crisp, crunchy, and have a drier texture.

Your Go-To Guide For:

Heavy Cream vs Whipping Cream ↗
Oat Milk vs Almond Milk ↗
Olive Oil vs Vegetable Oil ↗
Gelato vs Ice Cream ↗
Teaspoon vs Tablespoon ↗
Baking Soda VS Baking Powder ↗

For more articles, check out: KoolKitchen.pk ↗

Conclusion

In the end, the decision between brown and white sugar comes down to personal taste. Their health impacts are the same, and they are nearly comparable in terms of nutrition. Just keep in mind that consuming too much sugar might be harmful to your health. Use sugar wisely. The most important thing is to consume sugar in limited amounts, whether you choose brown or white sugar!